Skip to main content

Review of Peninsula Games, Fair Haven NJ

By

Our 3rd stop on our LGS jaunt was to Peninsula Games in Fair Haven, NJ. It was getting to be dark outside by this time, so we knew we may not be visiting these stores at the most lively times. 

Address: 775 River Rd, Fair Haven, NJ 07704

Website: peninsulagamesnj.com

Selection

Peninsula Games has a decent selection of Magic sets, Magic Secret Lairs, and board games. Their selection of Magic singles was robust with several well-organized binders with staples and cards of interest. 

"Their Warhammer selection seems somewhat eclectic and random. There wasn't a clear focus on newer or older figures, but not enough of either to cover the full gamut completely. Their Warhammer products are heavily focused on 40k with a lack of AoS." -Hskae

Cleanliness

Peninsula is a small store, and opposed to other newer stores, you can feel the history of the 4 years they've been there. I certainly wouldn't say the store is dirty per se, but its far from immaculate either. Peninsula has a very 'lived-in' feel. Their organization was clearly workable, but I'll admit I felt a little cramped. This may be due to an older building and poor use of space, however. 

Friendliness

The staff at Peninsula were pretty placid when we entered, clearly focused on building or painting figures. When we engaged them, however, they were very friendly. I appreciate being allowed to peruse without pressure. When asked about singles they offered their expansive selection of singles binders for us to browse. You can tell the associate who we were mostly talking to works well as a team with the owner who was working in the back. 

Play Space/Events

To our count, Peninsula has 3 tables set up for games and events. I don't know how else they would arrange their space, but the table setup seemed slightly awkward to me. But hey, you have to work with the space you have. 

Halfway through our visit two patrons who were clearly regulars entered and got settled at the store. The familiarity and casualness with which they were greeted was impressive. They set his stuff down, said they thought they should get some food, and left. Clearly, Peninsula is their Third Place. 

I might feel a little cramped to attend a pre-release at Peninsula, but I cannot say I don't think I would have fun. 

Value

Despite having a large selection of Magic singles for various formats, I was slightly disappointed to hear they base their prices off Channel Fireball, which is, in our experience, consistently higher than TCGPlayer market prices. 

You could find deals on certain items, however Warhammer and board games were typically MSRP. Magic packs were sold for what's expected.

Final Thoughts

Peninsula Games gives me the impression that it is especially beloved by its regulars, even if it doesn't seem to be all that impressive to someone just passing through, like we are. At the end of the day, however, an LGS is built on community and loyalty, which I have no doubt Peninsula has from its local patrons. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review of Warhammer Store, Matawan NJ

By
Our second stop on our trip to Cape May lead us to the Warhammer store in Matawan, NJ. We've visited the Warhammer store in Concord, DE before, but I wanted to see how this one compares. Address: Colonial Drive 1121, NJ-34 Suite 1121-N, Matawan, NJ 07747 Website:  https://www.games-workshop.com/en-US/Warhammer-Holmdel Selection Let me be clear - a Warhammer store is exactly what it is supposed to be: a Games Workshop proxy for Americans to buy and peruse their models. Are these stores still LGS'? Yes. Do they get a pass on not having MTG products et all? Yes. If your hobby of choice is Warhammer (40k or AoS, Blood Bowl, Warcry/Kill Team, or anything else GW related), the Warhammer stores provide a lot of services other LGS' simply can't. If you want something AoS or 40k related, this store has it or can acquire it easily. Other Games Workshop product is sort of random, with more KT/Warcry than any sort of Blood Bowl support. They also keep a healthy amount of codexes an...
Post a Comment
Read more

Review of The Gamer's Edge, Stroudsburg PA

By
We visited The Gamer's Edge on our way to an Airbnb we rented for Friendsgiving in the Poconos. This store is beautifully situated along a bustling main street in Stroudsburg with plenty of shops and restaurants. I wished we had more time to walk around, exploring the area, however we had just enough time to pick up boxes of Crimson Vow, a single or two, and get on our way. Address:  580 Main St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360 Website: thegamersedgecomics.com Selection Many stores seem to favor either "general nerd store" or "come here just to play Magic." This is not the case with The Gamer's Edge as they have both breadth and depth of selection. At the front of the store you'll find a good selection of board games and posters, etc, but as you continue you'll find a healthy selection of comics, Warhammer sets, vintage toys, vintage controllers and accessories, general nerd paraphernalia, and even painted Warhammer figures for sale. Beyond the high-value sing...
Post a Comment
Read more

Review of Red Seal Gaming, South Amboy NJ

By
Our first stop on our 6-LGS extravaganza as we meandered out way down to Cape May was Red Seal Gaming, a smaller and newly founded LGS in South Amboy. Address: 103-B North Stevens Avenue South Amboy, NJ 08879 UPDATED Address: 419 NJ-34  Matawan, NJ 07747 Website: redsealgaming.com Selection Red Seal Gaming offers a decent selection of the most recent products for Magic, Pokémon, Warhammer, D&D, and board games. Because they opened recently, you may be hard-pressed to find anything printed in the past; however they did have every Magic set going back to Guilds and Allegiance, which recently rotated. They don't yet offer Magic singles,* but I can easily forgive this as they are a new store and said they hope to do so in the future. * See update below as this has changed. "As a note on Warhammer selection - while Red Seal only has the bleeding edge of Warhammer models (printed last 2 years, focus on newest 9th edition pieces), the owner is willing to special order from GW to ...
Post a Comment
Read more